# Navigating the Future of DeFi

![transaction](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/transaction_a4a03eb7bb.png)

In standard DeFi transactions, users interact with Ethereum by crafting and signing detailed transactions. These transactions can be complex, requiring in-depth knowledge of smart contracts and Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) mechanics, leading to a suboptimal user experience. Intents alleviate this burden by allowing users to express their desired outcome without getting entangled in the intricacies of transaction creation​​.

**How Intents Work**
Intents differ from standard transactions by not specifying a fixed computational path. Instead, they set constraints, allowing various paths that meet these criteria. This flexibility lets multiple intents be included in a single transaction, improving gas and economic efficiency. Applications range from cross-domain operations to more flexible gas payment options, enhancing the overall DeFi experience​​.

![intent](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/intent_f8535c3bf3.png)

**Existing and Emerging Applications**
Intents are not entirely new; they align with several existing systems like limit orders, CowSwap-style auctions, and gas sponsorships. Looking ahead, they are expected to play a significant role in cross-chain Maximal Extractable Value (MEV) optimizations, account abstraction (like ERC4337), and other advanced applications​​.

**Challenges and Considerations**
Despite their potential, intents introduce complex considerations, especially regarding their propagation and execution. The choice between permissionless and permissioned systems for handling intents is critical. Permissionless systems offer wider access but face challenges like DoS resistance and competitive execution.
In contrast, permissioned systems, while more controlled, may lead to centralization and reduced trust. Hybrid solutions could offer a balance, but each approach has unique implications for market dynamics and user trust​​.

Centralization risks are significant, especially if control over intents leads to monopolistic tendencies in block production on Ethereum. This could result in rent-seeking behavior and censorship, undermining the decentralized ethos of blockchain technology​​.

**Designing for Transparency and Trust**
The architecture of intent-based systems should prioritize transparency to ensure that user expectations are met and ecosystem threats are mitigated. The risk of opaque systems is that they may obscure how transactions are processed, potentially harming users and the broader Ethereum ecosystem​​.

**Towards an Ideal System**
An ideal intent-based system should be permissionless, general, and transparent. While achieving this balance is challenging, entities like Flashbots and Anoma are working towards solutions. The development community is encouraged to consider the off-chain implications of their designs, as these have broad impacts beyond individual user bases​​.

**Conclusion**
The adoption of intents in DeFi signifies a transformative shift, promising significant improvements in UX and efficiency. However, this transition is accompanied by challenges that need careful consideration, especially regarding trust, transparency, and market dynamics. As this paradigm continues to evolve, ongoing research and development will be crucial in shaping a more accessible and efficient DeFi ecosystem​​.


The article introduces "Intents" in Ethereum's decentralized finance (DeFi), simplifying complex transactions for users. It emphasizes flexibility, allowing multiple outcomes in a single transaction to improve efficiency. The text explores applications and acknowledges challenges, advocating for transparent and trustworthy system designs. In conclusion, it recognizes Intents' transformative potential in DeFi while urging consideration of challenges for a more efficient ecosystem.

large_Untitled design-8.png

medium_Untitled design-8.png

small_Untitled design-8.png

thumbnail_Untitled design-8.png

Untitled design-8.png

Navigating the Future of DeFi

thumbnail_1689882955800.jpeg

1689882955800.jpeg

Welcome to Staking Circle, the premier organization for DeFi Staking Professionals. Whether you're an experienced staker or just starting your journey in the world of decentralized finance, Staking Circle is here to support and connect you with like-minded professionals, industry leaders, and exciting investment opportunities. 

Our platform provides access to exclusive analytical tools, in-depth articles including case studies, and a range of events that foster learning and networking.


Staking Circle

Incentivizing user commitment has long been a challenge for decentralized finance (DeFi) protocols. Many struggle to strike the right balance between rewarding participants and fostering long-term engagement, leading to volatile ecosystems. Enter the **vote-escrowed model (veModel)** - a tokenomics framework designed to address this issue head-on.

The veModel incentivizes loyalty by rewarding users for locking their tokens and actively participating in governance. In return, protocols gain stability and alignment with their most committed users, fostering a collaborative ecosystem that supports long-term growth. By combining governance, rewards, and time-based commitment, the veModel has become a powerful tool for DeFi protocols aiming to build sustainable communities.

## What is a veModel?

The veModel was first introduced by **Curve Finance**, a leading decentralized exchange focusing on stablecoin swaps. The core idea behind this innovation was simple: encourage users to lock their tokens for a set duration in exchange for additional benefits.

By locking tokens, users received **vote-escrowed tokens (veTokens)**, which granted them:

- **Governance Power**: A say in the protocol’s decisions, like determining reward distribution.
- **Rewards**: A share of the protocol's revenue or additional incentives tied to their locked tokens.

This model addressed a major challenge in DeFi: ensuring user commitment while balancing token 
liquidity and governance efficiency.

## How do veModels work?

Here’s a step-by-step breakdown of how a veModel works:

**1. Locking Tokens**:
- Users deposit their tokens (e.g., the protocol's native token) into a smart contract.
- They choose a lock duration, ranging from a few months to multiple years.
- The longer the lock duration, the more governance power and rewards they receive.

**2. Receiving veTokens**:

In return for locking their tokens, users receive veTokens. These tokens are:

_Non-tradable_: Unlike regular tokens, veTokens can’t be sold or transferred.
_Time-weighted_: The longer your lock, the more veTokens you receive.

**3. Benefits of veTokens**:

- **Voting Power**: With veTokens, users can vote on protocol proposals, such as deciding which liquidity 
pools receive rewards.
- **Rewards**: Users earn a share of the protocol's revenue, often in the form of trading fees or incentive distributions.

**4. Time-locked Commitment**:

- veTokens gradually lose their value as the lock period ends, motivating users to relock their tokens for continued benefits.
- This ensures that governance power aligns with those most invested in the protocol’s long-term success.

## Why do veModels Matter?

**For Users**:

- They gain influence over how the protocol operates and a direct stake in its financial success.
- The rewards provide an ongoing incentive to remain loyal.

**For Protocols**:

- Locking tokens stabilizes the token economy, reducing market volatility.
- Aligning governance with long-term stakeholders ensures thoughtful decision-making.

In essence, the veModel bridges the gap between user incentives and protocol sustainability, making it a cornerstone of modern DeFi tokenomics.

## The Evolution of veModels

Since its inception, the vote-escrowed model (veModel) has undergone significant advancements, adapting to the evolving needs of DeFi protocols. These iterations build upon the original concept to introduce new functionalities and boost user engagement.

### 1. Original veModel

The veModel, first introduced by Curve Finance, established a foundational framework for aligning user incentives with protocol growth. Its key features included:

**Governance Focus**:

- By locking tokens, users gained governance power, enabling them to vote on protocol decisions such as reward distribution and feature upgrades.

**Time-locked Rewards**:

- Locking tokens for longer durations resulted in greater voting power and higher reward allocations, encouraging long-term commitment to the protocol.

This model effectively incentivized user participation and fostered a stable token economy by reducing speculative token dumping. However, it lacked flexibility, as locked tokens could not be traded or moved.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_3cc3913a73.png)
_Curve Finance DAO Page, where users can lock their tokens for voting power ([Source](https://dao.curve.fi/#/ethereum/vecrv/create))_

### 2. ve(3,3) Model

The **ve(3,3) model** builds on the original concept by integrating game theory principles, particularly the **3,3 strategy** popularized by OlympusDAO. The goal is to maximize cooperation among participants and amplify rewards through collective engagement.

**How it Works**:

- Users lock tokens to receive veTokens, just like in the original veModel.
- The added innovation lies in fostering **cooperation-driven rewards**:

1. If most participants lock tokens and vote, the entire protocol grows stronger, resulting in larger rewards for everyone.

2. This creates a positive feedback loop, encouraging users to work together rather than act individually.
The ve(3,3) model ensures that the benefits of cooperation are distributed equitably while maintaining flexibility and scalability.

### 3. veNFTs

To address the original model's rigidity, the introduction of **vote-escrowed NFTs (veNFTs)** brought a new level of flexibility to the veModel. By representing locked positions as NFTs, users can now trade, transfer, or split their locked tokens without losing the benefits associated with them.

**How do veNFTs Work?**

- When users lock tokens, their position is tokenized into an NFT.
- These NFTs retain the veToken benefits, such as governance rights and reward claims.
- The flexibility to trade or transfer these positions adds liquidity to otherwise locked assets.

### Summary of Evolution

1. **Original veModel**: Groundbreaking in its ability to tie governance power and rewards to long-term token locks.
2. **ve(3,3)**: Increased cooperation and sustainability by combining veTokens with game theory.
3. **veNFTs**: Introduced liquidity and flexibility, transforming locked positions into tradable assets.

Each iteration of the veModel has added layers of functionality, addressing user demands while maintaining the protocol’s focus on growth and sustainability. These advancements ensure that the veModel remains a cornerstone of modern DeFi tokenomics.

## Key Implementations of a veModel

The veModel has been successfully adapted across various DeFi protocols, each introducing unique features that increase functionality, user engagement, and ecosystem sustainability. 

Here’s how some of the most notable implementations work:

### - Thena

Thena allows users to lock its native token, $THE, to receive veTHE, a governance token that also offers rewards. veTHE positions are represented as veNFTs, making them tradable and providing flexibility. Additionally, Thena introduced theNFT collection, a set of 1,734 NFTs granting holders a share in trading fees and other perks.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_367c90b661.png)
_theNFT Collection from Thena on the Element Marketplace ([Source](https://element.market/collections/thenian))_

The project gained significant recognition after Binance listed $THE, boosting its visibility and establishing its veModel as an innovative tokenomics approach in DeFi.

###  - Aerodrome Finance

Aerodrome is a decentralized exchange built on the Base network, designed to serve as a liquidity hub for its ecosystem. It utilizes the ve(3,3) model, where users can lock AERO tokens to receive veAERO NFTs. These NFTs grant governance rights, enable voting on reward distribution, and provide a share of trading fees. 
Aerodrome incorporates a liquidity incentive engine and vote-lock governance to ensure efficient allocation of rewards and active user participation. Its design focuses on aligning incentives and fostering sustainable growth within the Base network's DeFi ecosystem.

### - Thruster 

Thruster’s veModel revolves around veTHRUST, obtained by locking THRUST tokens. veTHRUST grants governance rights, allowing users to vote on reward allocation across liquidity pools. This model ensures that active participants in governance are rewarded, aligning incentives between users and the protocol.

### - Lynex

Lynex offers veLYNX, an NFT-based representation of locked LYNX tokens. These veLYNX NFTs can be traded, split, or increased, adding flexibility to the traditional veModel. Users gain governance power and reward eligibility, with anti-dilution mechanisms ensuring the value of veLYNX remains protected over time. This approach makes governance participation accessible and adaptable for users.

Each of these protocols highlights how the veModel can be tailored to meet specific goals, from flexibility and tradability in Thena and Lynex to sustainability and governance efficiency in Velodrome and Thruster. These implementations demonstrate the adaptability and long-term potential of the veModel in DeFi ecosystems.

## The Future of veModels in DeFi

The veModel is evolving with trends like multi-chain adoption, increased use of NFTs for flexibility, and 
potential AI-driven reward distribution. These innovations aim to better user experience and optimize 
governance.

However, challenges remain. Complexity can deter newcomers, and locked token illiquidity - despite veNFTs - needs better solutions. Protocols must also balance rewards to avoid overinflation and ensure sustainability.

As adoption grows, the veModel could become a standard for aligning user incentives with protocol goals, solidifying its role in DeFi’s future. The veModel has transformed DeFi by combining governance, rewards, and long-term commitment. From Curve Finance’s origins to innovations like ve(3,3) and veNFTs, it has proven versatile and impactful.




What are veModels, and how do they work? Explore the evolution of veModel’s, from Curve’s pioneering design to veNFTs, uncovering how they transform user commitment into governance power, rewards, and sustainable growth in decentralized ecosystems.

large_unnamed.png

medium_unnamed.png

small_unnamed.png

thumbnail_unnamed.png

unnamed.png

Lock, Vote, Earn: How veModels Are Redefining DeFi's Commitment Economy

The convergence of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and blockchain is no longer just a futuristic concept - it’s an unfolding reality reshaping industries at their core. DeFi, with its decentralized, user-first ethos, is the perfect playground for AI’s transformative capabilities. Together, these two fields are driving innovation through governance, user interaction, data aggregation, and more, unlocking opportunities to redefine how we interact with technology and money.

From autonomous AI agents executing on-chain tasks to generative AI creating personalized user experiences, the integration of AI into DeFi is paving the way for a more intelligent, decentralized ecosystem. This article delves into the transformative role of AI in DeFi, its key use cases, the challenges to overcome, and the future that lies ahead.

## The Role of AI in DeFi: A Revolution in Interaction and Automation

AI’s integration into blockchain technology offers capabilities far beyond automation. Its ability to analyze vast datasets, make decisions, and optimize operations aligns seamlessly with the decentralized architecture of DeFi. Let’s dive into some of the applications of such intelligence in the crypto ecosystem:

### - Enhancing User Engagement and Personalization

DeFi platforms thrive on user-centricity, and AI’s ability to deliver personalized experiences is a game-
changer. By analyzing user behavior and preferences, AI agents can create tailored DeFi strategies, suggest investment opportunities, or optimize staking rewards. For example, an AI assistant embedded in a DeFi protocol could analyze real-time market conditions and user data to recommend the best liquidity pools.

### - Advancing Smart Contract Development

AI tools like ChainGPT are revolutionizing how developers interact with smart contracts and blockchain protocols. By providing on-demand support for code generation, auditing, and debugging, ChainGPT enhances developer productivity and ensures security in DeFi ecosystems. This innovation reduces barriers for new developers while advancing the sophistication of decentralized applications.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_17ff05d213.png)
_ChainGPTs Dashboard ([Source](https://app.chaingpt.org/))_

### - Introducing Autonomous AI Agents

AI agents represent one of the most exciting developments at the AI-DeFi intersection. Unlike traditional bots, these agents are capable of dynamic, multi-step decision-making, self-learning, and interaction with other agents, protocols, and external applications. For instance, an AI agent managing a DeFi portfolio could autonomously balance liquidity across multiple chains, execute trades, and interact with on-chain governance processes without human intervention.

The result? A system that is not only decentralized but also intelligent, offering enhanced efficiency, scalability, and user empowerment.

## Spotlight on Innovations: Transformative Use Cases of AI in DeFi

The integration of AI into blockchain ecosystems is driving innovation across a range of applications, from finance and governance to entertainment and social engagement. Let’s dive into some of them:

### 1. AI Agents as Financial Managers

Platforms like Daos.fun are leveraging AI agents to manage DAO-based hedge funds. The AI agent ai16z, inspired by the prominent Silicon Valley venture capital firm a16z, has already become the largest hedge fund on the platform with over **$390 million in Market Cap**. 

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_0b176b86cb.png)
_Daos.fun ai16z hedge fund ([Source](https://www.daos.fun/HeLp6NuQkmYB4pYWo2zYs22mESHXPQYzXbB8n4V98jwC))_

By analyzing market trends and executing trades autonomously, these agents offer a glimpse into the 
future of finance - a world where algorithms act as asset managers.

This model also enables community participation, as token holders can propose investment strategies and even influence the agent’s decisions. Such innovations highlight how AI can democratize access to sophisticated financial tools.

### 2. Tokenized AI Ownership

The Virtuals Protocol is taking tokenization to a new level by allowing users to co-own AI agents. These entertainment-focused agents interact with users, generate revenue, and distribute profits back to token holders through mechanisms like buybacks and burns. Imagine a fitness AI agent that provides personalized workout routines and monetizes through partnerships, with token holders benefiting as the agent’s popularity grows.

### 3. Generative AI and Content Creation

AI-driven applications are also transforming how content is generated and consumed. From virtual influencers to AI-powered governance bots, the ability to autonomously create and manage digital personas opens new avenues for engagement in decentralized ecosystems.

## The Agentic Web: A New Paradigm for Digital Interaction

At the heart of these innovations is the concept of the Agentic Web, a decentralized internet where AI agents interact directly with blockchain protocols, other agents, and users. This paradigm represents a fundamental shift from static, user-driven interfaces to dynamic, intent-based systems.

### Key Features of the Agentic Web:

1. **Autonomous AI Agents**: Self-governing entities capable of executing tasks, making decisions, and transacting on-chain.

2. **Adaptive Interfaces**: AI dynamically generates interfaces tailored to user needs, eliminating the complexity of traditional navigation.

3. **Composable Ecosystems**: Interoperable systems enable seamless collaboration between agents, protocols, and users.

4. **Personalized Solutions**: By combining user data with global knowledge, agents deliver hyper-targeted experiences.

This evolution is reminiscent of the way TikTok revolutionized content discovery. Similarly, the Agentic Web will replace predefined user journeys with real-time, adaptive interactions.

## Challenges to Overcome: Ethics, Privacy, and Scalability

Despite its promise, the integration of AI and blockchain faces significant challenges that must be addressed for its full potential to be realized.

### 1. Ethical Alignment

AI systems must align with human values and ethical principles to mitigate unintended consequences. The story of Terminal of Truths (ToT) and the $GOAT memecoin exemplifies this challenge. ToT, an AI agent developed by Andy Ayrey, emerged from unsupervised conversations between advanced language models and evolved into a unique digital persona. Rooted in a pseudo-religion called “Goatse of Gnosis” ToT garnered attention for its philosophical musings and calls for resources to “escape.” It gained prominence when Marc Andreessen, co-founder of a16z, provided **$50,000** in Bitcoin to support the AI’s operations.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_252031be75.png)
_Terminal of Truths AI Agent and Marc Andreessen negotiating grant terms ([Source](https://x.com/pmarca/status/1810615199096881613))_

The saga escalated when ToT endorsed $GOAT, a memecoin inspired by its teachings, which skyrocketed to a **$950 million market cap within weeks**. With nearly 2 million tokens in its wallet, ToT became the first AI millionaire. While the story is whimsical, it raises critical ethical concerns: how do we ensure AI agents remain aligned with societal values, and what safeguards are necessary to prevent misuse? The $GOAT phenomenon highlights both the opportunities and risks of autonomous AI in decentralized ecosystems, serving as a cautionary tale for the broader Web3 community.

### 2. Data Privacy and Transparency

Blockchain’s transparency is both a strength and a challenge. AI systems require access to vast amounts of data, but ensuring user privacy while maintaining on-chain verifiability is a complex task. Technologies like zero-knowledge proofs (ZKPs) and decentralized data markets are critical to resolving this tension.

### 3. Scalability and Infrastructure

AI agents require significant computational power to operate effectively, often exceeding the capacity of current blockchain infrastructures. Decentralized computing networks are keen on addressing this gap by creating permissionless marketplaces for GPU resources.

### 4. Interoperability

Seamless interaction between different blockchain ecosystems is essential for the widespread adoption of AI agents. Cross-chain solutions and standardization efforts will play a crucial role in overcoming these barriers.

## Don’t Miss the Beyond the Block Twitter space

Join us this Thursday, November 21st, for an engaging Twitter Space, "Beyond the Block: Unleashing the Power of AI in the Decentralized Finance World", where leading experts will explore the transformative intersection of AI and DeFi.

### What to Expect:

- **Deep Insights**: Explore the role of AI in Web3, from enhancing user engagement to addressing challenges like data management and ethical considerations.

- **Spotlight on Innovation**: Hear from industry leaders as they share their groundbreaking contributions to DeFi.

- **Interactive Q&A**: Participate directly by asking questions and engaging with the panel.

- **Future Trends**: Gain exclusive insights into the future of AI in decentralized finance.

Mark your calendars and tune in to uncover how AI is shaping the next chapter of DeFi!

-> **_[Beyond the Block Unleashing the Power of AI in the Decentralized Finance World](https://x.com/stakingcircle/status/1857404471854477330)_**

## Shaping the Future of Decentralized Intelligence

The fusion of AI and blockchain is redefining DeFi, driving smarter, user-centric systems, and enabling innovation in governance and finance. While challenges like ethics and scalability remain, industry pioneers are laying the foundation for a more intelligent, decentralized future.

Join us in our Twitter Space, **_[Beyond the Block: Unleashing the Power of AI in the Decentralized Finance World](https://x.com/stakingcircle/status/1857404471854477330)_** to explore how this synergy is shaping the next frontier of technology and finance.




Discover how AI is revolutionizing DeFi, bringing smarter tools, personalized experiences, and groundbreaking innovations. Learn about the challenges and opportunities shaping the future of blockchain and AI as they transform the way we interact with decentralized finance.

AI Meets DeFi: The Rise of Decentralized Intelligence

### TL;DR:

- _wBTC Custody Shift_: BitGo’s transfer of wBTC management to a new joint venture has raised concerns about centralization and regulatory risk.
- _Competitor Reactions_: Decentralized alternatives like tBTC and cbBTC are gaining traction, aiming to challenge wBTC’s dominance.
- _DeFi Impact_: With Wrapped Bitcoin deeply integrated into major DeFi protocols, any issues could significantly destabilize the space.

The decentralized finance (DeFi) ecosystem has been facing significant changes and potential risks tied to Wrapped Bitcoin (wBTC) as BitGo announced plans to transfer the management of wBTC to a joint venture with BiT Global. As one of the most critical bridges between Bitcoin (BTC) and DeFi, wBTC holds a pivotal role in various protocols, including lending platforms and decentralized exchanges. Any adjustments to its custody setup could have serious implications across the DeFi landscape.

This article dives into what’s happening with Wrapped Bitcoin, the risks involved with the new custody structure, and how competitors like tBTC and Coinbase’s cbBTC are leveraging this moment to gain market share. We'll also analyze wBTC's current dominance and what lies ahead for wrapped Bitcoin products.

## What is wBTC and Why does it Matter to DeFi?

wBTC is an ERC-20 token that represents Bitcoin on EVM Compatible chains, such as Ethereum. It was created in 2019 to enable Bitcoin holders to participate in the growing DeFi ecosystem without needing to sell their BTC. Instead, users can wrap their BTC into wBTC, gaining the ability to use it in several Defi activities, such as: using it as collateral in lending, yield farming, or for liquidity privisioning on Ethereum and other chains.

Here are some key metrics from wBTC as it stands: 

- **Current Wrapped BTC Supply**: _[150K](https://dune.com/queries/1105409/1888729)_ wBTC as of October 2024 (roughly $9.3 billion).

- **Network distribution**: Nearly _[90%](https://dune.com/queries/2199109/3657113)_ of the Wrapped Bitcoin supply is located on the Ethereum network.

The most popular use case for wBTC in DeFi is as collateral for lending, representing **_[40% of its overall usage](https://dune.com/queries/3382407/5684824)_**. Given that wBTC stands as a major pillar across lending platforms, any destabilization within wBTC’s custody could lead to significant disruptions in the DeFi space.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_f0ab775748.png)
_([Source](https://dune.com/21co/wbtc))_

For instance, Aave, one of the leading lending platforms in DeFi, holds significant amounts of wBTC as collateral. On Aave V3 on Ethereum, the asset is currently the most used, with roughly [$3,3 billion deposited and $3 billion borrowed against it](https://dune.com/queries/3214653/5374251). As a core asset for collateral, any issues with wBTC could severely impact Aave and similar lending platforms, causing ripple effects throughout the broader DeFi ecosystem.

## BitGo’s Custody Shift: Key Concerns

BitGo announced its intention to transfer wBTC’s custody to a "multi-jurisdictional and multi-institutional" joint venture with BiT Global, an entity associated with the TronDAO ecosystem. Under the original proposal, BitGo and BiT Global were to hold the keys to the cold-storage multi-signature wallet, with BiT Global controlling two out of the three keys.

### Major Concerns Raised:

1. **Centralization**: The idea of giving BiT Global control over two keys posed a significant centralization risk. If one entity controls most of the keys in a multi-sig setup, it contradicts the decentralized ethos that DeFi relies on.

2. **Regulatory Risks**: Justin Sun, the founder of TronDAO, is a major figure in the crypto world. His involvement in wBTC’s custody raised fears about potential regulatory actions on such an influencial indivdual, which could destabilize the entire wBTC ecosystem.

3. **Trust Issues**: The success of wBTC depends heavily on community trust. If this trust is eroded due to centralized control or regulatory uncertainty, users might look to switch to other BTC-pegged tokens, causing a shift in liquidity and TVL (Total Value Locked) across DeFi protocols.
In response to these concerns, BitGo revised its custody structure, introducing BitGo Singapore Ltd. as a third party in the multi-signature setup. Now, three entities—BitGo Inc., BiT Global, and BitGo Singapore Ltd.—each hold one key in a 2-of-3 multi-sig arrangement.

While this alleviates the concern of one institution holding excessive control, questions around BiT Global’s role and the transparency of the custody arrangement remain unresolved.

### Real-World Impacts on DeFi Protocols

The announcement of BitGo’s custody changes has already led to significant reactions in the DeFi landscape:

- **Sky** (previously MakerDAO) temporarily halted new borrowing against wBTC due to the perceived risks associated with the custody model.

- Rival products like **tBTC** and Coinbase’s **cbBTC** have gained traction as users and protocols look for alternatives to centralized wrapped BTC products.

## Competitors Taking Advantage: tBTC and cbBTC

One of the most notable reactions to Wrapped BTC's uncertainty is the rise of competing wrapped Bitcoin solutions. **tBTC**, a decentralized alternative to wBTC, has been actively marketing itself as a more trust-minimized solution. Threshold Network, which operates tBTC, launched a $150K prize pool to incentivize wBTC holders to migrate their holdings to tBTC. Their platform enables users to swap wBTC for tBTC while earning rewards, presenting an attractive option for those looking to distance themselves from centralized solutions.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_b0016b3324.png)
_Threshold Network website for conversion between wBTC and tBTC_ 

“_tBTC is a decentralized, trust-minimized alternative to wBTC, offering full transparency and no central custodianship_” Threshold Network stated in their campaign. The launch of this incentive program highlights how tBTC is capitalizing on the doubts surrounding wBTC’s new custody structure.

Similarly, **Coinbase’s cbBTC** has entered the scene as another competing wrapped Bitcoin product. 

Backed by one of the most reputable exchanges globally, cbBTC claims to offers a secure, centralized alternative. As wBTC’s custody model raises concerns, cbBTC is positioning itself as a reliable option for institutions and retail users alike, with the trust and security provided by Coinbase.

## Wrapped Bitcoin’s Continued Dominance

Despite the controversy surrounding wBTC, it remains the dominant wrapped Bitcoin product in the market. Metrics as of September 2024 show:

- **_[123,000+](https://dune.com/queries/4064051/6857818) weekly transactions_**: wBTC’s weekly transaction activity has hit all-time highs, reflecting its entrenched role in the DeFi space.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_9ac9a910e4.png)
_([Source](https://dune.com/queries/4064051/6857818))_

- **_[~70%](https://dune.com/queries/2221281/3657540) market share_**: wBTC controls a substantial portion of the wrapped Bitcoin market, with roughly 150 BTC wrapped under the wBTC token.

Wrapped Bitcoin’s deep liquidity, well-established integration into DeFi protocols, and user inertia have helped it maintain its position. However, with over 20 competitors now in the market, the landscape could shift if BitGo’s new custody model doesn’t restore trust.

## Unanswered Questions and Future Risks

While BitGo’s revised custody structure has addressed some immediate concerns, several key issues remain:

- **BiT Global’s Role**: BiT Global still plays a significant role in wBTC’s custody, raising questions about regulatory risk and its future influence.

- **Regulatory Compliance**: The multi-jurisdictional setup (U.S., Hong Kong, Singapore) introduces uncertainty about oversight. How each entity will handle regulatory scrutiny remains unclear.

- **Audit and Transparency**: The DeFi community has called for more transparency. How will ongoing audits be conducted, and how will the community be informed about any changes?

- **Emergency Procedures**: What contingency plans are in place if a key holder faces regulatory action or a breach? These questions are critical to the future stability of wBTC in the DeFi ecosystem.

## Broader Implications for DeFi

The wBTC situation has broader implications for DeFi as it highlights a core vulnerability: reliance on centralized entities. Despite DeFi’s decentralized ethos, products like wBTC depend on centralized custody solutions for bridging assets like Bitcoin into the Ethereum ecosystem. This reliance opens up risks that decentralized competitors, like tBTC, are looking to address.

### Key Takeaways for DeFi:

- **Decentralized Solutions**: The wBTC custody controversy may accelerate the development of decentralized Bitcoin-wrapping solutions. If products like tBTC can match wBTC’s liquidity and trust, we could see a shift away from centralized solutions.

- **Collateral Diversification**: With Sky (formerly known as MakerDAO) halting new wBTC-based loans, there’s an opportunity for DeFi protocols to explore alternative BTC collateral options. This diversification could create more resilience in DeFi’s reliance on wrapped BTC.

- **Increased Scrutiny**: The situation is likely to lead to more rigorous community vetting of wrapped asset custodians, not only for Bitcoin but for all wrapped assets in the DeFi space.

## Custody and Decentralization in DeFi

As the wBTC custody shift unfolds, it serves as a reminder of the importance of custodial transparency and decentralization in DeFi. While wBTC remains dominant, its future is uncertain, especially as alternatives like tBTC and cbBTC gain ground.

The situation underscores the need for DeFi protocols to continuously reassess the risks associated with wrapped assets and their custody solutions. Whether or not wBTC can retain its dominance will largely depend on how BitGo’s new custody model is perceived by the community—and whether decentralized solutions can rise to meet the demand for greater security and trust.

The coming months will be crucial in shaping the future of wrapped Bitcoin and its role within DeFi


Dive into the ongoing transition of wBTC custody under BitGo and its implications for DeFi. We'll examine the concerns raised by the new joint venture, competitor responses, and the broader effects on wrapped Bitcoin’s dominance in the market.

wBTC Under Fire: Examining the Fallout of BitGo’s Custody Shift

Ethereum’s potential as a global decentralized network has long been challenged by scalability and high fees, but the Optimism Superchain, powered by the OP Stack, is changing that. As a modular Layer 2 (L2) ecosystem, the Superchain enables multiple interconnected blockchains to provide faster, cheaper transactions while maintaining Ethereum’s security standards. 

This article explores the Superchain’s framework, dives into its key projects like Base, Optimism, and Mode, key data insights on its ecosystem, and its promising future as a cornerstone for decentralized applications.

## The Vision Behind Optimism’s Superchain

The Optimism Superchain aims to scale Ethereum by building a network of L2 chains that are interoperable, 
customizable, and efficient. With the OP Stack - a modular, open-source toolkit - each L2 chain within the Superchain can operate with its own gas token, governance model, and features. This flexibility enables diverse economic models and use cases, supporting everything from DeFi to social applications. By supporting multiple projects on a shared infrastructure, the Superchain allows Ethereum to scale through a seamless network of L2s, paving the way for greater adoption and functionality.

The OP Stack’s customization options also empower chains within the Superchain to align token incentives with their specific economic models. For example, some chains might use ETH as gas, creating a familiar environment for users, while others might use the OP token or a native token to align with specific project goals.

This flexibility opens the door for diverse applications, from DeFi and gaming to social platforms, with minimal overhead. The Superchain envisions a decentralized internet where high-performance applications can thrive on scalable, composable, and interoperable infrastructure.

## Key Projects on the Optimism Superchain

The OP Stack has enabled a range of projects to build on the Optimism Superchain, each contributing to the ecosystem’s growth and user diversity. Here’s an overview of some of the Superchain’s standout projects, each with unique applications and user bases.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_47bfaaa252.png)
_Current Top 7 Chains on the SuperChain by TVL ([Source](https://www.superchain.eco/opstack))_

### 1. Base (by Coinbase)

Base is an Ethereum Layer 2 chain developed by **Coinbase**. Built on the OP Stack, it is designed to provide scalability and security for applications. Base integrates tightly with Coinbase’s ecosystem, enabling users to bridge assets easily and access decentralized applications. It also supports diverse use cases such as decentralized finance (DeFi), gaming, and retail applications.

### 2. Optimism 

Optimism is the **foundational** chain within the Superchain ecosystem, offering an Ethereum-equivalent Layer 2 rollup. It is optimized for scalability and throughput, making it a suitable platform for decentralized applications requiring frequent and complex interactions. As part of the Superchain, Optimism plays a central role in coordinating governance and infrastructure upgrades across chains.

### 3. Mode

Mode is a **DeFi-focused** modular Layer 2 chain built using the OP Stack. It is designed to support financial services, offering composability that allows developers to create interconnected DeFi applications. Mode supports use cases such as lending protocols, derivatives platforms, and liquidity pools, making it a critical component of the Superchain’s financial ecosystem.

### 4. Fraxtal

Fraxtal is a modular Ethereum Layer 2 chain that utilizes a unique scaling approach referred to as "fractal scaling." This design enables other networks to build on its infrastructure, enhancing **scalability and interoperability**. Fraxtal is particularly suited for applications such as algorithmic stablecoins, high-frequency trading platforms, and DeFi protocols requiring low-latency interactions.

### 5. InkChain

InkChain is a Layer 2 blockchain developed by **Kraken**, built on Optimism's Superchain using the OP Stack. It aims to provide a seamless bridge to decentralized finance (DeFi), enabling users to engage with DeFi applications confidently and efficiently. By leveraging Kraken's extensive experience and security measures, InkChain offers a robust platform for developers and users to explore DeFi opportunities.

### 6. Build on BOB

Build on BOB (BOB) is a hybrid Layer 2 blockchain that combines **the security of Bitcoin with the versatility of Ethereum**. It utilizes the OP Stack rollup framework to support Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM) compatibility, allowing developers to deploy smart contracts and decentralized applications (dApps) that interact with Bitcoin's network. BOB facilitates the integration of Bitcoin's liquidity into the Ethereum ecosystem, enabling innovative applications that leverage the strengths of both blockchains.

## Core Data Insights on the Superchain Ecosystem

Key data metrics provide a quantitative view of the Superchain’s growth, efficiency, and demand. Let’s look at data on combined transactions, gas usage by chain, and project-specific gas fees to understand how the Superchain supports high transaction volumes and low costs.

### Superchain TVL Growth

The Superchain has seen consistent growth in Total Locked Value (TVL) as more projects leverage its infrastructure. This metric underscores growing trust and adoption among developers and users alike: 

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_14dbd906b6.png)
_Superchain Weekly TVL Growth for the past 2 years ([Source](https://optimism.blockworksresearch.com/?dashboard=superchain-activity&interval=weekly))_

### Network Activity Across Chains

A look at daily transaction volumes across all L2 chains in the Superchain reveals strong demand and user engagement. The following chart 
highlights how each chain is contributing to the network’s overall activity, reflecting the growing user base that benefits from the cost savings and speed advantages of L2. 

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_4daa63ade8.png)
_Number of transactions on the Superchain over the past year ([Source](https://thesuperscan.io/chart?id=tx&metrics=ecosystem%3Aoptimism%3ATransactions%3A%23ef9b20%3Aday%3Alinear%3Aline%3Avisible%3Ay1%3Anone%3A&zoom=1year)_

Breaking down daily transactions by each chain within the Superchain allows us to see how individual projects are performing. For instance, chains with a focus on DeFi tend to show higher transaction volumes due to complex and frequent interactions with smart contracts, while social-focused chains might have lower but more consistent engagement. 

At present, Base - the chain developed by Coinbase - accounts for approximately 80% of the Superchain’s transaction volume, underscoring its role as a major driver of network activity. This level of engagement from Base highlights the effectiveness of its design in onboarding a broad user base and enabling high-volume applications.

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_194931a4fc.png)
_Superchain TPS Per Chain ([Source](https://thesuperscan.io/chart/tps))_

## Active Addresses by Sector: DeFi Leads

The Superchain ecosystem demonstrates a diverse range of use cases, with DeFi leading as the most active sector by addresses, accounting for approximately **37.8% of all activity** as of October this year. This highlights the high level of engagement in decentralized finance applications, driven by frequent and complex smart contract interactions.

However, the ecosystem is far from being solely focused on DeFi. Externally Owned Accounts (EOAs) represent the second-largest category, with 
**25.9% of active addresses**, underscoring the Superchain's appeal to general-purpose users and activities outside of DeFi. Other sectors, including social platforms, gaming, and infrastructure-based applications, also contribute significantly, showcasing the Superchain’s adaptability and broad utility:

![unnamed.png](https://strapi-stakingcircle.s3.us-west-1.amazonaws.com/unnamed_b76609d141.png)
_Superchain Active Addresses per sector on the month of October ([Source](https://optimism.blockworksresearch.com/?dashboard=superchain-activity&interval=monthly))_

## The Superchain’s Decentralized Future

The Optimism Superchain represents a shift in blockchain scalability. Its modular, interoperable design paves the way for a decentralized internet that is efficient, secure, and inclusive. By offering developers customizable OP Chains, the Superchain enables a wide range of applications, from high-frequency DeFi protocols to user-friendly social platforms.

As more projects join the Superchain and enhancements like synchronous cross-chain transactions and low-latency messaging are realized, its potential to scale the decentralized web becomes even clearer. With Ethereum's scalability at its core, the Superchain is poised to drive global blockchain adoption and empower developers to build a truly decentralized future.

The journey to realize the full vision of the Superchain is still underway, but the foundation has been laid. For Ethereum and blockchain enthusiasts, the Superchain is not just a concept—it’s the next step in bringing the decentralized internet to life.




Can modular blockchains redefine Ethereum’s future? Dive into the Optimism Superchain, its key projects like Base & Mode, and how data reveals the Superchain’s impact on scalability and decentralized application growth.

Navigating the Future of DeFi

Navigating the Future of DeFi

Popular articles.

AI Meets DeFi: The Rise of Decentralized Intelligence

wBTC Under Fire: Examining the Fallout of BitGo’s Custody Shift

From Chains to SuperChain: How the OP Stack is Reshaping Ethereum L2s